Monorail - Can routes be improved ?
- Bangalore |
- Transportation |
- Public Transport |
- monorail |
- public transport |
- metro |
- monorail |
- Analysis
- Naveen's blog
- Login or register to post comments
- Forward this Blog entry
Praja.in comment guidelines
Posting Guidelines apply for comments as well. No foul language, hate mongering or personal attacks. If criticizing third person or an authority, you must be fact based, as constructive as possible, and use gentle words. Avoid going off-topic no matter how nice your comment is. Moderators reserve the right to either edit or simply delete comments that don't meet these guidelines. If you are nice enough to realize you violated the guidelines, please save Moderators some time by editing and fixing yourself. Thanks!
Comments
Monorail - Expensive fare, Route improvements
Kanesan Veluppillai, president, Scomi International, said the monorail will have a carrying capacity of 10,000 people with 139 persons per car. The capacity might be increased to 30,000 depending on the demand. Initially, there will be four cars.
“We are expecting the cabinet’s nod to start the project. We have submitted the DPR in October 2009. We hope to get the approval by this year. From the date of signing the contract, it will take 30 months for completion of the project,” said Kanesan.
“The monorail project is aimed at attracting private vehicle users and helping them move away from use of private vehicles. Hence, the fares will be three times higher than bus rates,” he said.
Scomi International Limited plans to set up monorailmanufacturing units. The units will be in four states including Karnataka. “Once work on the second and third projects starts, the units will be set up. This will be done in the next five years,” said Kanesan.
(Excerpts from a previous media report)
Routes can be improved for better commuter convenience as follows :
1) Shantinagar /Lalbagh:
If the green mono route (marked 'A') turns right into KH rd & then turns left into Siddiah rd, instead of continuing along Lalbagh north boundary wall (after KH circle), it would interface well with shantinagar TTMC, if a stop /station were provided at the intersection of Siddiah & KH rds.
Further, if the route continues along Siddiah rd upto JC rd & is routed along JC rd instead of Lalbagh rd, it would include catchment on Lalbagh rd (if a stn is provided where it crosses it) as also cover JC rd /Townhall /SJP /NR rd. This will mean additional stations & added investments, but increased ridership levels may offset it easily. Track length will remain nearly same.
2) Koramangala:
If the blue & green Mono routes ('A' & 'D') interface at the fork where the two hosur rds meet (Madiwala checkpost), & if the blue route goes along Kml 80-ft rd (that starts opp Forum mall) instead of following Kml 100-ft rd, it would allow the route to turn right into 80-ft peripheral rd (near Kml indoor stadium), then turn left into IRR towards Domlur. This would cover more shopping /comml catchment areas on the two 80-ft roads in Kml as also include 100-ft rd at Sony world jn, integrating well with Kml TTMC too, whilst going past Bethany school on one of the two 80-ft rds.
3) Indiranagar:
Instead of routing the blue line all along 100-ft rd in Indiranagar, the route could turn right into 12th main (also 80-ft wide) & proceed to Indiranagar 80-ft rd, turn left & run north along the 80-ft rd to reach old madras rd. This way, it will have catchment from 100-ft rd as also 80-ft rd, Jeevanbhimnagar /Thippsandra rds which are adjacent Indiranagar 80-ft rd, both of which are comml. Addnl stn/s may be necessary, but ridership will increase due to better coverage - trackage will remain nearly same.
4) Jayanagar:
Though this would increase track distance, connecting 3rd/4th blocks on the red ('B') route could be considered since most of the comml activities are situated there (there is also the Jayanagar TTMC). If this route were to proceed further south past madhavan park to 4th block (along 9th main, which is 100-ft wide), then turn west on 30th cross at Jayanagar TTMC & then proceed north along Kanakapura rd (or KR rd) to reach NR colony, it will cover much wider areas (interface with Metro can be at Jayanagar metro stn; Southend circle will not be covered, but since Metro covers it, the need becomes much lesser).
three times cost = auto cost!
Three times bus ticket cost will be equal to auto costs..
so today three people can pool in to travel by auto instead of bus ..since the cost works out to be the same..
when the monorail comes in..if at all..then it will be the most expensive mode of transport..way too expensive to the common man!
Two Monorails ?
Some monorail lines are marked as CTTP monorails (in light blue, along Bannerghattta road) and some are marked as Scomi Geodesic monorails. What is the difference ?
Two Monos
Hi Ashok_n,
The CTTP monorails are those recommended by traffic survey in 2007. GoK is pursuing monorail only along ORR-west & on Magadi rd (Bannerghatta rd will have Metro in ph-2 from IIMB to Nagwara instead of Monorail).
Scomi Geodesic monorail routes have also been proposed by them separately to GoK & the 1st route (Green line from Agara lake to Majestic) has been approved by GoK, as a pilot project.
Ring Roads need not have mono Rails
I would say we do not need mono rails or metros at the ring roads as they have enough space to have a seperate lane for buses - costs involved would be way too less ... BRTS might be a better option..
Read this - http://business.rediff.co...