Skip to Content

Bangalore Metro Stations - Artist's Impressions

7 October 2007 - 1:31pm — tsubba

We now have renders for all the stations on Stretch I, Phase I of Bangalore metro- MG Road, Trinity Circle, Halsoor, CMH Road and Old Madras Road. Only the terminal at Byapanahalli and oh, I forgot the new station KR Puram remain. :)

MG Road Station Renders

OMR and Halsoor Renders

Is BMRC spending money on glitz which could otherwise have been used to lay more metro lines? or is glitz necessary to overcome public perception about public transport? If they come out as designed will these stations showcase brand bangalore?

Image Source: BMRC's pdf

ಪ್ರತಿಕ್ರಿಯೆಗಳು

raghu1122000's picture

Glitz ... I think its needed

raghu1122000 - 10 Jul 2008 - 12:53pm

Well, a couple of things to point out. I have noticed not in one but many many forums, that people have made it a point to be critical of bangalore .

 Not that it is wrong, because constructive criticism always enhances the development of a city but let us be a little circumspect in doing so.

First let me quickly point at the Bangalore airport. Hardly have I seen anyone praising it. To put it more frankly

The new airport is not as bad as it is made out to be . Sure it could have been better but remember this is a start to what is to be expanded as a massive aerotropolis. So lets not start bashing even before things are completed.  

 Now coming to the metro. The gentleman above has indicated that it has too much glitz. Again absolutely nothing wrong at all in having such good looking stations. Who ever said  airport is the only point of contact to the outside world. Even today people appreciate the london metro (yes agreed because of its higher connectivity) instead of the Heathrow. So if we do have such futuristic looking stations it certainly is only going to do good. I personally feel in such mega projects, even if the progress is a little slow , we need to think of designs that are not outdated 10-15 years down the line..Well thats my opinion really... 

 And are we complaining of traffic in Bangalore.. hey I have stayed in various cities in India.. Delhi, Mumbai, Pune, Chennai and ofcourse my home town bangalore.

 Forget the other big cities.. Just as a case in point I will take pune as an example. To cover a distance of 10 Km when it took me around 45 minutes in bangalore  in peak traffic conditions , it took me 50 minutes for the same distance in pune (This was just done for academic interest).

 So my friends lets not be always critical of our city just for the heck of it . Every city has problems and worse than what we have(ask me about it). Let us all encourage if the government is trying to do something  nice to resolve traffic conditions( which exists in every city). So much hue and cry for the Hyderabad airport being opened first but not a word about them lagging behind in the metro project.

 

blrsri's picture

halasuru station construction starting

blrsri - 16 Apr 2008 - 10:28am

http://www.deccanherald.com./Content/Apr162008/city2008041662949.asp

time for a reality check..if the artist who drew up the above pictures was just a very creative person or we really are implementing the way it was projected..I am sure the above set of fotos created news in the world of infrastructure all over the world..

need to see how it comes up!

btwn Halsuru was so named cos of lot of halasu(jackfruit) trees there..how about reviving this by planting halasu trees in parks and streets..

bangalorean's picture

Stations designs seems to be too Optimistic

bangalorean - 16 Oct 2007 - 3:47pm
I can feel that the designs are very optimistic. Really can they build such designs .. have to wait and watch .. ha ha ha...
Arun's picture

Colonial buildings too...

Arun - 16 Oct 2007 - 10:56am
Well, I should have included colonial structures as well along with structures built using traditional/local architecture. The facade of Cochin Airport is another eg. Bombay's VT, Mys Rly Stn or Chennai Central are distinct again for their architecture. On that count, Blr Rly Stn is only a contractor's pride. The Colonial powers that rules us, had to make significant changes to suit the local climate. But not our present day builders and 'architects'.
Arun's picture

Traditional touch to the stations

Arun - 15 Oct 2007 - 4:03pm
These stations look really hep. Bangalore has lost one too many heritage landmark structures in the last decade. Wherever possible, BMRCL and BMTC should try to bring them back on the map. Too much of glass, metal...too much of sunlight/heat getting rebounded, resulting in high usage of ACs in the stations as well. Namma Metro should think about going green in every aspect. Get designers to design stations on the lines of local architecture (look at this - http://www.flickr.com/sea... & http://upload.wikimedia.o...).
blrsri's picture

what is local architecture?

blrsri - 15 Oct 2007 - 4:38pm
They used to say that the Vidhana Soudha was the first secretrait which had an Indian design..all other states used the colonial bldgs.. We have set precedence then..but have stopped after that.. All our new buildings now sport a glass facade..which by design is not for tropical climes..but who cares? silicon valley does so we do! Bangalore was the 'garden city'..maybe we can use that cue and have lots of greenery around! Rangolis decorating the floors(though the airport is not using it after Praful Patel wanted a 'international' look instead)
tsubba's picture

land

tsubba - 8 Oct 2007 - 5:46pm
land acquisition problems i think is the main bottleneck.
blrsri's picture

private vs govt

blrsri - 8 Oct 2007 - 4:49pm
Flyover on hosur road, that work has started on, is being put in place at a break neck speed.. Amazing to see such fast pace.. BIAL airport is also working fast towards realization BMRCL is busy moving one tree a week!! why? cant they emulate the private guys? why not implement instead of building dreams?? I am sure no one will ever say no to a functional station if it serves the purpose..I am sure no one will ask for the neon signage instead of tubelights if the trains are on time!!
Vasanth's picture

BMRC is making public transport attractive

Vasanth - 8 Oct 2007 - 7:51am
As said by TS in one of the comments on BMTC, BMRC is making all the stations look 'sexy' and there by attract non public transport users and public transport haters mainly from rich and upper middle class people to take up metro. Will we have even mono stations like this?
tsubba's picture

haha

tsubba - 7 Oct 2007 - 8:19pm
hahaha... i guess it has become second nature for me to be cynical of everything. :) but BIAL you see is different. Point of contact to the world. Could have been KA's gateway to the world, and World's window to KA
Naveen's picture

Metro Stations, Byappanahalli Depot

Naveen - 7 Oct 2007 - 5:05pm
Hi all ! These station designs appear very contemporary, if one considers the design elements elsewhere in the world, like the new Beijing airport, new Berlin Rly station & St.Pancras at London (which is going to handle superfast TGV trains from Paris via the chunnel). To leverage on it's prominent IT /Outsourcing capital status, planners have come out with great designs that may propel the city further into the 'big league' of cities ! I dont beleive that there will be any extensions to the Metro on the E-W line, though there had been a recent news report. The reason is obvious - commuter rail services on existing tracks were already being planned linking Mysore road terminal with Kengeri (via Nayandahalli) & Byappanahalli with Whitefield (via KR-Puram). So, where's the need to extend ? Byappanahalli station is being planned on grade (the Metro alignment ramps down there to road level). There is a land plan on the BMRC web site for the Byappanahalli yard /depot.
silkboard's picture

nothing bad with glitz

silkboard - 7 Oct 2007 - 2:32pm
- feel good thing for citizens - attract more citizens (aka customers) - showcase brand bangalore as you said - (and perhaps, deflect public attention away from its design and operating costs - a point we have been debating around vikash's post) And its not that jazz like this always has a high cost. What we got to see is 'maintenance', because thats one thing we suck at as a nation. Public, even public-private bodies suck at maintaining structures and amenities. Anyway. So how about Byappanahall?. I am curious to know the design etc because South Western Railway is also going to build a terminal there. How will the two terminals (Metro, SWR) sit with each other? will they share any resource? How well will the two be connected? Thats why the curiosity. Tarle, time to pull your leg now. Tell me one thing. BIAL looks 'simplistic', you were a bit disappointed. Metro stations have too much jazz and glitz, you raise a concern. Whats the sort of 'look' that you prefer in these projects :)

Praja.in comment guidelines

Posting Guidelines apply for comments as well. No foul language, hate mongering or personal attacks. If criticizing third person or an authority, you must be fact based, as constructive as possible, and use gentle words. Avoid going off-topic no matter how nice your comment is. Moderators reserve the right to either edit or simply delete comments that don't meet these guidelines. If you are nice enough to realize you violated the guidelines, please save Moderators some time by editing and fixing yourself. Thanks!



about seo | story