Skip to Content

Questions on legislative functioning

up
462 users have liked, including you.
Governance

The people be damned — no one cares about the delay in the GST or the land acquisition law or the lives of the jobless young — as long my salary as an MP is doubled.

Instead of wringing our hands in dismay, we can implement some fairly simple political reforms. First, force our Speakers to exercise powers that they already possess in order to discipline rowdy, disruptive members. Irish MPs in Britain used to be physically picked up by marshals and thrown out onto the street until they realized that the punishment was too costly. Second, make MPs work longer. Why does India’s Parliament meet for 67 days in a year when Britain’s meets for 150 days and the US Congress for 200? Why is our monsoon session only for three weeks and not three months? Allow Parliament to be summoned if two-thirds of the members want it, as in the UK. Give the opposition a chance to let off steam and set the work agenda. In the UK, leader of the opposition sets the agenda for 20 out of 150 days.

Third, India should adopt fixed-term elections, as the UK has just done and other democracies did long ago. Whereas the Constitution envisaged a five-year electoral cycle, state governments have insisted on falling, upsetting the cycle. If legislatures had a fixed term, they would not be hostage to the whims of the leader of the majority party. Elections would be held on two fixed dates, every five years at the Centre and every two-and-half years in the states. If a government fell in a no-confidence vote, the House would not be dissolved; legislators would be forced to cobble a new government or face President’s rule. LK Advani suggested fixed-term elections; Sharad Pawar endorsed it and included it in the Nationalist Congress Party’s manifesto. Manmohan Singh and Pranab Mukherjee liked the idea but the UPA did not implement it. Today, the Nachiappan Committee is seriously examining it. Although Advani wanted simultaneous state and central elections, I think an interim date, halfway through the five years, gives some protection against an unusually foul government.

The fourth reform is to replace the present ‘no-confidence motion’ with a ‘constructive vote of non-confidence’ as in Germany, which means you can only bring down the government if you have an alternative in place. This will also bring more stability. Finally, separate legislators from sports bodies. Lalitgate may not have happened if sports officials had to resign by law on the day that they became legislators. A successful democracy is, in the end, a daily performance and it is time we looked our legislators in the eye, reminding them that pigs can’t fly nor walk on two legs, and do not take us for granted.


For the full text of the column by Sri Gurcharan Das in the Sunday ToI, click here.

Last evening, Sri Gurcharan Das brought up this matter during an NDTV debate, though strangely it did not seem to generate much of a debate. I am however of the view that it does merit a debate, and if it can't happen on NDTV, let it happen on Praja.

Shouldn't we be making the parliamentarians earn at least some part of the repeat salary and perks increases they have been awarding themselves, on the already substantial existing levels?

While the column has been written about the Parliament, I expect it applies equally to the state legislatures too. The accountability needs to be across the board.

Muralidhar Rao

Comments

murali772's picture

why a whole day just for homage?

up
166 users have liked.

Won't grudge MPs salaries, freebies if they did some work. 1st end day-1 adjournment after obituaries. A 5-min break will be homage enough.

The above text of a tweet by Shekhar Gupta I thought was very relevant to the context here.

Muralidhar Rao

Praja.in comment guidelines

Posting Guidelines apply for comments as well. No foul language, hate mongering or personal attacks. If criticizing third person or an authority, you must be fact based, as constructive as possible, and use gentle words. Avoid going off-topic no matter how nice your comment is. Moderators reserve the right to either edit or simply delete comments that don't meet these guidelines. If you are nice enough to realize you violated the guidelines, please save Moderators some time by editing and fixing yourself. Thanks!



about seo | blog