Skip to Content

Using the present Indian railways as Commuter rail in Bangalore

up
270 users have liked.
Commuter RailPublic Transport

For the past month or so, i have been regularly using the IR trains running between cantonment station and whitefield station to commute to my office near Whitefield.  I am travelling by train only in the mornings, as the frequency is decent. Its a struggle to find trains in the evenings.  I find the trains reliable and on schedule  most of the time. Surprisingly there are quite few of folks from IT sector already using this service regularly for office commute. Approximate travel time from cantonment station to whitefield station is 40  min with 2 minute stops at East station, byapannahalli station and K R puram station.  Find below my schedule for the trains....


And cost for passenger trains in Rs.3/- and express trains Rs.25/-. 
It would good if more people start using the existing trains for daily commute and create a pressure on system so that IR will actually introduce commuter trains. Let me know if anyone needs more info on how to use IR trains for city commuting.

Regards,

 

Comments

j_venu's picture

is taking cycles in train allowed ?

up
94 users have liked.

I had also tried,  it is mostly on schedule , Tickets in passenger train is very cheap. There are monthly passes available also.

However   hopping using bus from  home –station   and again  station – office  (hebbal  - cantonment  bus ,  cantonment – kr puram  train ,  Kr puram to Mahadevpura – by bus )  takes  lot of time .  My experience is direct buses  fare better with respect to time when I consider my overall travel time . ( bus  + train = 1:20 mins, only bus – 1 hr)

 I am not sure If they allow taking cycles in Passenger Trains,  any information on the same would be helpful.

RKCHARI's picture

Further Info Required

up
118 users have liked.

Dear Vinod & Venu,

Would either of you be able to give me similar train timing chart on the reverse side - i.e. from Whitefield to Contonement or City Station?

I live in Whitefield and have often to take a train to Chennai . Is there anyway I can hop on to this IR trains at appropriate time to reach City/Cantonement from where I could catch the Chennai Train?

Any light on this aspect would help please.

Regards,

Chari

RKC

vinod_shankar's picture

@venu & Chari

up
93 users have liked.

@Venu:  I haven't seen anyone taking their cycle along, i doubt if there is any provision to carry cycles as these passengers trains are mostly Mainline EMU's.    But may be u can park your cycles at the stations

I agree it doesn't work for you because u travel from hebbal to mahadevpura.  Its useful for me because, from home i reach cantonment station by bus in 15 min + 40 min train journey+15 min from whitefiled station to my office at varthur kodi by big-1 bus.  If i do the same journey by taking a bus to shivajinagar and then to varthur..on an average it would take me 1hr 30min to reach office, and on some bad days it can go upto 2 hours also.  The train provides reliability in terms of average time taken to reach office, which the bus doesn't.  One other big releif, unlike roads is there is no constant honking/pile up of vehicles.  The comfort factor is high in a train.

@RK Chari

Please find the data you requested in the following link.  Whitefield-to-Bangalore city junction

Regars,

vinod

 

idontspam's picture

Shame we have to workaround

up
100 users have liked.

Admit we are resourceful, but, I think it is pathetic we have to make do with such workarounds while SWR/GoK cannot work out a mutually beneficially CRS for this city utilizing prime land within the city. 

Meanwhile, here is a bicycle enabled train. If we have a commuter rail to Tumkur, Mysore, Doddballapur etc we may be able to run one of these.

kbsyed61's picture

Vinod, Good Job!

up
109 users have liked.

Vinod,

Thanks for the very good information and am sure you are motivating others to make use of the existing choices. I am in agreement with you that SWR can certainly help the city commuters by extending little help.

Any ideas how SWR can help for the return journey in the evenings? Should it run some short distance trains say at a freq of 30-40 minutes?

Syed

vinod_shankar's picture

A few suggestion to make it better

up
112 users have liked.

No. Name Type From Dep To Arr Travel Time Dep Days
6521 Bangalore Express Exp WFD 22:28 BNC 22:53 0 h 25 min S M T W T F
101SR Arakkonam Bangalore ... Pass WFD 17:50 BNC 18:24 0 h 34 min S M T W T F
2609 Bangalore Express Exp WFD 19:02 BNC 19:36 0 h 34 min S M T W T F

There are only three trains in the evening, out of which two are express trains making it diffcult to travel by trains in the evening.    SWR should introduce a few more passengers trains from bangarpet-ramanagaram in the evening.   SWR should should stop terminating of all mysore-bangalore passenger trains at the city junction and extend them all the way to whitefield-malur.  

Vinod

 

 

Raghu Nandana M's picture

More Intra Cuty Trains

up
113 users have liked.

Have a few ideas !!! Let me know if this helps.

1.Third Line between Bangalore to Ramanagaram.-Pressure by means of political will needs to be extended.You could look at chennai as an example where the presence of third line and fourth line  has helped ease traffic into the city of chennai.Doubling is just one step.The railways need to plan for the future.

2.Electrification of Bangalore -Tumkur(Currently Double Line).Electrification would aid more MEMU Trains which are in sync with the latest trends and would faciltate growth of tumkur as a suburban town to bangalore.

3.Doubling of  Yeshwantpur-Yelahanka and Yelahanka-Chanasandra lines which has been allotted a paltry amount of 1crore in the budget ,2009 this year.At This rate it would be impossible to complete this line for decades .

Electrification i believe is the essence towards faster rail conectivity inside the city as it is non polluting and also aids in increasing the speed of rails.

The present leadership by Mr.Muniyappa (MOS-Railways )should take personal initaiative towards facilitating commuter rail system in bangalore.

RKCHARI's picture

Thanks a million Vinod for

up
99 users have liked.

Thanks a million Vinod for that link on the Whitefield to Bangalore City Station timings. Have taken a print out and pasted it on my desk!

Cheers.

Chari

RKC

Vasanth's picture

EDGE Stations...

up
98 users have liked.

 We discussed the edge stations earlier:

http://www.praja.in/en/blog/silkboard/2008/09/01/edge-stations-ring-rail-and-leasing-or-acquiring-swr-assets.

Metros and Monos are expensive stuff. Tracks within the city is highly valuable resources which needs to be best utilized. Just like satellite bus stations we need to have satellite railway stations at Yelahanka, Whitefield, Kengeri and Yeshwantpur. All the long distance trains needs to terminate here. These outer stations needs to be connected using circular track outside the city for trains passing by Bangalore as well as goods trains. Tracks within the city needs to be well used for Local Commuter Train.

Also the edge stations should have good parking facility. After this point, vehicles entering the city should be tolled heavily to reduce the vehicle entering the city so that people coming in private vehicles to the city can park their cars at the edge stations and take the commuter rail or city buses.

This may trouble people entering Bangalore city centre by train especially for elders and women since they have to change over trains, but, valuable resource of track within the city can be better utilized reducing the congestion and pollution.

Other option is to have few limited trains entering city station instead of every train plus track quadrapling wherever land is available.

 

RKCHARI's picture

Good Suggestions

up
128 users have liked.

Dear Vasanth Sir,

I think these are excellent suggestions. I dont know why people in the Railway Board / Ministry and BMRCL authorities cannot think sanely like this? As in all cases related to infrastructure, Government's right hand does not know what the left is doing. Pity, clear thinking persons like yourself are not in the bureaucracy willing to take on the "system" in its entirity.

Best wishes & regards,

Chari

RKC

Praja.in comment guidelines

Posting Guidelines apply for comments as well. No foul language, hate mongering or personal attacks. If criticizing third person or an authority, you must be fact based, as constructive as possible, and use gentle words. Avoid going off-topic no matter how nice your comment is. Moderators reserve the right to either edit or simply delete comments that don't meet these guidelines. If you are nice enough to realize you violated the guidelines, please save Moderators some time by editing and fixing yourself. Thanks!



about seo | blog